The Curse of Oak Island Season 12: 1700s Artifact Stuns Experts!i

Hey guys, Oak Island continues to deliver the unexpected. Just when you think the legendary treasure hunt couldn’t get any more thrilling, the team stumbles upon something truly fascinating: a small yet incredibly ornate button hidden within an ancient stone structure on Lot 5.

But here’s the kicker: this button might just hold the key to unlocking one of Oak Island’s oldest secrets. What if I told you that a single artifact, no larger than a coin, could connect to a mystery dating back to the 1600s? That it could tie into secret Freemason conspiracies, lost Spanish treasure, and even one of the most infamous treasure hunters in history?

Well, buckle up, because this discovery is more than just a button—it’s a symbol of a story that has remained buried for centuries. Let’s dive deep into the latest mind-blowing find from The Curse of Oak Island Season 12 and what it could mean for the treasure hunt.

The discovery takes place on Lot 5, a significant area on the western side of Oak Island. For years, this particular site has been a source of intrigue, yielding artifacts that hint at a long lost history predating The Money Pit itself. But now, the Oak Island team, led by Rick Lagina, archaeologist Fiona Steel, and the legendary metal detection expert Gary Drayton, are investigating a peculiar stone foundation that seems to be hiding something extraordinary.

As they scan the area, the metal detector starts to beep wildly, indicating the presence of metal buried within the stone structure. This isn’t just another rusty nail or an old iron tool. This time, the signal is different. It’s non-ferrous, meaning it’s not iron. It could be copper, lead, or even gold. You can almost hear the excitement in Gary’s voice as he exclaims, “That could be a coin!”

But what they actually uncover is even more surprising: a small, intricate button unlike anything they’ve seen before. At first glance, the button appears corroded, covered in layers of timeworn patina. But as archaeologist Laird Niven carefully examines it, something astonishing is revealed: it has a floral design, intricate and ornate, suggesting it could be hundreds of years old.

The button’s craftsmanship hints at an era when items were not just functional but also symbolic. It’s a small but significant artifact that could date back to the 1700s or even earlier.

And here’s where things get really interesting: this particular button might be directly connected to one of the most compelling theories about Oak Island’s legendary treasure. Could this be a remnant of the long-rumored Spanish treasure, or does it belong to a secret society that once used Oak Island for something far more mysterious?

To understand the significance of this discovery, we need to go back to the 17th century and talk about a man named Sir William Phips. In 1687, Phips was ordered by King James II of England to recover lost Spanish treasure from a shipwreck known as La Concepción, a Spanish galleon that sank near the Dominican Republic. Phips, along with his assistant and high-ranking Freemason Andrew Belcher, managed to recover an enormous amount of silver and gold. But here’s the mystery: only a fraction of the treasure ever made it back to England. The rest? Well, some believe it was hidden somewhere secret—somewhere like Oak Island.

Over the years, researchers have speculated that Phips and Belcher may have used Oak Island as a hidden vault for their treasure, burying it deep within the island’s legendary Money Pit. Now, with the discovery of this button, potentially from the late 1600s or early 1700s, could we finally have a tangible link between Oak Island and the missing Spanish treasure?

But we’re not just relying on theories here. Thanks to modern technology, archeo-metallurgist Emma Culligan conducted an X-ray fluorescence (XRF) analysis on the button, and what they found was truly incredible. The XRF scan revealed an elaborate floral design on the button—something not visible to the naked eye due to centuries of corrosion. The intricate pattern suggests high craftsmanship, likely European in origin, possibly even English.

Gary Drayton, with his deep knowledge of historical artifacts, suggests that this could be a jacket button—not from an ordinary coat, but perhaps from a high-ranking military officer, a nobleman, or even a Freemason. The ornate design suggests status, wealth, and possibly a connection to someone important.

Could this button have belonged to Sir William Phips himself? Or was it left behind by one of his men, a silent witness to a secret mission carried out centuries ago? Every discovery on Oak Island adds another piece to the ever-growing puzzle. This button, small as it may be, might serve as a key link between the artifacts already uncovered and the greater mystery that still lies beneath the island’s surface.

Let’s not forget, this isn’t the first time Lot 5 has yielded remarkable finds. In the same area, the team has discovered 17th-century trade beads, possibly from early European traders or explorers, iron tools linked to Sir William Phips—strengthening the theory that he was involved with Oak Island’s mysterious Money Pit—and material which matches the deep soil samples found in The Money Pit area.

Put all of this together, and we have a compelling case that something of immense historical value is buried within Oak Island. Now, with this new discovery, the Oak Island team is more determined than ever to keep digging—both literally and figuratively. They plan to conduct further testing on the button, hoping to uncover more details about its origins. Could this lead to more evidence of Phips’ lost treasure? Could it support the long-standing theory that Oak Island was used as a secret repository for stolen Spanish silver and gold?

One thing’s for sure: this button is just the beginning. And let’s not forget what Gary Drayton said: “There are only three metals that make that sound—copper, lead, or gold.” Could there be more artifacts hidden within the stone structure? Maybe even coins, relics, or something far more valuable?

We can only hope that in the next episodes of The Curse of Oak Island, the team will uncover more secrets that bring us closer to solving one of the greatest treasure mysteries of all time. Oak Island is not just a site of scattered artifacts—it’s a place with a purpose, a hidden agenda that has kept treasure hunters, historians, and theorists searching for over two centuries. A button, though small, can be a symbol of who was here, why they came, and what they left behind.

If this button dates back to the late 1600s or early 1700s, as suspected, then it could be one of the earliest pieces of evidence linking Oak Island to a structured European presence before the famed discovery of The Money Pit in 1795. It could indicate that whoever left it behind wasn’t just passing through—they were actively working on something deliberate, secretive, and possibly grand in scale.

One of the most persistent theories about Oak Island is that the legendary Money Pit and surrounding structures were not built by pirates, but by Freemasons, a secretive society known for their cryptic symbols, deep ties to history, and mastery of engineering. If Sir William Phips and Andrew Belcher were indeed connected to Oak Island—and if they were high-ranking Freemasons—then this button could be a small but crucial link in a centuries-old conspiracy to hide something of immense value.

Freemasons were known to use intricate designs and symbols in their clothing, buildings, and even their artifacts. Could this ornate floral design be a Masonic emblem? Could it mark the presence of someone involved in an elaborate plot to safeguard treasures? If that’s the case, then we might not just be dealing with a treasure hunt—we might be uncovering the remnants of a secret society’s mission.

Lot 5 is quickly proving to be one of the most important sites on Oak Island. At first, it seemed like just another section of land with scattered relics, but with every new discovery—17th-century beads, iron tools linked to Phips, and now this intricate button—it’s becoming clear that something significant happened here. Unlike other parts of Oak Island, which have been extensively searched and excavated, Lot 5 has remained relatively untouched for decades. That means its artifacts might be some of the most authentic, undisturbed pieces of evidence linking Oak Island to a historical event that predates the well-known 1795 Money Pit discovery.

If there was ever a time to focus efforts on a specific part of the island, Lot 5 might just be the key to unlocking the entire mystery. If one button can generate this much excitement, imagine what else could be buried within the stone foundation and surrounding areas. Could more personal artifacts from Phips’ men be hidden in the ground? Perhaps gold coins, tools, or even documents proving what they were doing here? The possibility is tantalizing.

The Oak Island team knows they are onto something big. This isn’t just another random artifact. It fits a timeline, it fits a theory, and it fits a bigger picture that is slowly coming into focus. Every discovery brings us closer to unraveling a story that has been buried for over 300 years. With the button now undergoing further analysis, the Oak Island team is more motivated than ever to expand their search, dig deeper, and uncover more relics that could finally confirm their theories.

As the season progresses, we can expect more shocking discoveries, more evidence connecting the past to the present, and maybe—just maybe—the long-awaited breakthrough that will change Oak Island history forever. The treasure hunt is far from over, and with every new clue, the excitement builds. Could the next find be the ultimate proof that Oak Island holds a hidden fortune? Stay tuned, because the mystery of Oak Island is only getting more thrilling.